I've always been intrigued by Hot Buttered Rum! When I set out to create our
New Hot Buttered Rum black tea, I had two goals in mind.
1. Include fresh ground spices in our tea (just like the best rum batter recipes).
2. Create a tea that would give new meaning to the traditional Hot Buttered Rum recipe drink.
There are endless Hot Buttered Rum recipes that call for hot water. As an admitted tea addict, tea seemed like the logical choice to give this drink a new lease on life. Tea is good for you, and using tea is an easy way to make something so sinfully decadent a little bit good.
What Is Hot Buttered Rum?
Hot buttered rum is traditionally made with rum, hot water, butter, sugar, and spices. It gained popularity before the American Revolution. The drink was made at home when rum was cheap and affordable. It's said that tea was kept in locked boxes but even the poorest farmer would offer his rum bottle to a stranger.
The concept behind hot buttered rum is to make a hot buttered rum batter. Historically, the batter is made with butter, sugar, and spices. This tradition is delicious, but it's not very pretty. Butter and water (even made into tea) don't really mix. The trick is to add an emulsifier or ice cream which already has emulsifiers. The addition makes the batter sweet and creamy. It also helps to blend all of the gorgeous ingredients for the big show!
Change it up!
There are endless possibilities to adapt this recipe! We have experimented with adding ground ginger and star anise. The best tip would be to use fresh-ground organic spices for the best batter results! Experiment and find what you like best.
Mocktail Tea Options
Try substituting any one of these suggested Tealightful tea blends!
Batter Base Options
It's Day 1 of Holidaze Sips recipe week, and today I bring you a recipe for a Hot Buttered Rum Tea Mocktail!
1 stick of room temperature butter
1/4 cup brown sugar
1/2 cup of room temperature vanilla ice cream
1 teaspoon cinnamon
1/2 teaspoon nutmeg
1/8 teaspoon clove
Optional honey to taste
1 tablespoon spiced batter
1/2 teaspoon of real vanilla extract - optional
8 ounces Hot Buttered Rum Tea
1/4 cup honey
1/2 cup brown sugar
Mix sugar, butter and ice cream together. Add spices and blend well.
Rim Glass with Honey & Sugar: Dip glass rim into a plate of honey and then into a plate of brown sugar.
Make the spiced butter: Mix the room temperature butter with the brown sugar, room temperature ice cream and spices. Use immediately or refrigerate until making the drinks.
To make the drinks: Add 1 to 1 1/2 tablespoons of the spiced butter to each glass. Add vanilla extract (or 2oz. of rum). Add tea and and stir until combined. Top with softened ice cream and cinnamon.
Experiment with all of the optional variations to create your own unique Hot Buttered Rum recipe.
You can also try this and more holiday/winter tea blends in our unique Holidaze Tea Sampler Box!
I just bought some vanilla ice cream today, so plan to try this tomorrow. Can’t wait!
I had such a fun time making this!
This blend is a favorite of many of my customers! Thanks for sharing! It sounds great!
I am so excited to try this. My two favorite drinks. Tea and Rum. Let the Holidaze begin.
This looks so delicious! I can’t wait to make it. I think it become a cold weather tradition!!
Wow! This recipe is fantastic! I plan on making it and it would be a fun drink for a tea party!
This sounds so good…might just have to go shopping for some additional ingredients not readily available in my home (like ice cream) :-)
This sounds delicious I can’t wait to try it!
OMG!!! I love the Hot Buttered Rum tea and this recipe sounds and looks like the perfect cup of joy for a cold night or afternoon!!
Comments will be approved before showing up.
November 17, 2020
Hot Buttered Rum is an amazing tea on its own! This recipe is one I will have to pull out and “wow” my friends and family with!